Questions to ask of a Foreland report
Nine questions a careful reader should put to any screening report, answered for ours. A report earns confidence by showing where it could be wrong.
What is it for?
To show what the mapped public datasets record on and near one site boundary in England, with the source and date of each, so that a professional knows what to investigate. It is a first screen.
It is not for deciding whether permission would be granted, for replacing a survey, or for being relied on as professional advice.
What does it work out, what does it take as given, and what does it leave out?
Worked out by Foreland
- For each source checked: whether a mapped feature is on the site, near it, or not returned
- Whether each source's coverage of the site is complete, partial or unavailable
- Measured distances, in the paid report
- The maps, the evidence and coverage register, the PDF and the GIS files
Taken as given
- Each publisher's dataset, at the release and date named in the report
- The site boundary supplied by the customer
- The search distances in Foreland's search policy, each with a written reason
Not considered
- Constraints that are not in any published dataset
- A planning officer's judgement and the planning balance
- Emerging local policy
- Objections from neighbours or others
- Anything a site visit or survey would find
Things are left out because no dataset exists for them, or because they are a professional's judgement. Leaving a thing out of a report is not a finding that it is absent.
How does it show what it does not know?
A source that could not be checked, or whose coverage of the site is incomplete, is shown as such. It is never shown as nothing found, and the part of the report it belongs to is marked partial.
For a typical site most sources read as coverage to verify, because few publishers state that their data is complete. That is the state of the published data, and the report says so.
Has any result been adjusted by hand?
Findings come from the query and the published rules. The written narrative may only restate findings; a narrative that does more is rejected before the report can be sealed. An issued report cannot be edited: a correction is a new report with a new ID.
While orders are few, a person at Foreland runs each order and looks it over before it is sent. That is a production check, not a professional review.
Can it be checked and replayed?
Each paid report is sealed when issued. The verify page shows whether a report ID is genuine, the release and publisher date of each dataset it used, and the date it was sealed.
The verify page confirms identity and provenance only. It does not confirm that the publisher's data was right on the day, and it says nothing about the condition of the site.
A report can be reproduced from its sealed pack without consulting current data. Today Foreland does that, not the reader. The engine is tested; it is not described as validated.
Who has reviewed it?
For a screening report, no professional. The verify record states it in these words: “no professional review has been applied and no professional reliance arises from it.”
A report reviewed and signed by a named professional is not part of a screening order.
How old is the data?
Each dataset in a report carries its publisher's date, and the verify page shows the age of each source when the report was sealed. Foreland has not yet set an age beyond which a source is treated as out of date, so read the date as part of the finding.
What happens if a rule or a dataset turns out to be wrong?
Each report records the dataset releases and the rule version it used. Foreland can list every report that used a given release or rule, and its procedure is to write to the holder of any report the fault changes. The corrected report is a new report; the old one is not altered.
What should a reader still do?
Check the planning authority's own registers wherever a source is marked incomplete, above all for conservation areas, tree preservation orders and Article 4 directions. Visit the site. Take professional advice before relying on any finding.
No model of the world can be shown to be true; it can only be tested (Oreskes and others, 1994; Forrester and Senge, 1980). This page describes the Planning and Environmental Constraints screening report as it is built today, and is updated when that changes.
Put the method against a real site
The free check reports each source the way the paid report does: on the site, nearby or not returned, with its coverage and its gaps. The paid report checks more sources and adds measured distances and the sealed pack.
Check a site